ABOUT THE GUI OF BONES IN SYNFIGSTUDIO
======================================
This document shows the current GUI of synfigstudio being developed and
the pending features that needs to be done. The things that already are
done are marked as (DONE) and the one pending are marked as (PEND).
For more information about how the bones works in synfig-core see the
corresponding document in synfig-core/trunk/docs/bones_core.txt (PEND)
PRINCIPLES
----------
1) The user should not need to edit the parms directly in the skeleton
or the blines unless a fine tuning or animation of the setup is
needed. (PEND)
2) The bones are visible when the user select a skeleton layer.(DONE) When
the user selects a layer that has a vertex under bone influence then
the corresponding bones are shown too (DONE)
BASIC USAGE -WORKFLOW
---------------------
1) The user draws its stuff using the usual tools.
2) The user creates a skeleton in not animation mode. This implies:
2.1) Add a bone
2.2) Remove a bone
2.3) (Re)parent a bone.
3) The user binds the vertex/blinepoint to the bone(s). This implies:
3.1) Select a vertex/blinepoint and assign bone(s) to it.
3.2) Modify the weights of each bone over the vertex.
4) In non animation mode the user "tests" the skeleton: is happy with
the current bind of the vertices or do a fine tuning.
4.1) Modify the ducks of the bones.
4.2) Modify the values of the weights.
4.3) (Re)Bind vertices to bones.
4.4) (Re)Parent bones.
5) The user changes to animation mode and animate the skeleton. This
implies:
5.1) Manipulate ducks
5.2) (Re)parent bones.
5.3) Modify the Link values of the bone influenced vertex/blinepoint.
5.4) Eventually modify the weights. (RE)Bind.
6) Eventually the user can animate the parent of the bones, the weight
influences values, the setup values, etc.
BONES DUCKS
-----------
Those are the bones parameters and its corresponding interface in the
edition window (GUI interface) and in the parameter panel (Param Interface):
Parameter name Type GUI Interface Param Interface
-------------- ---- ------------- ---------------
Name String <none> Edit string input
Parent Bone Value Node <none>(PEND) Drop down list
Origin Vector position duck (green) (real,real)
Angle Real angle duck (blue) real
Local Length Scale Real real duck (cyan) real
Local Width Scale Real width duck (purple) real
Recursive Length Scale Real real duck (cyan) real
Recursive Width Scale Real width duck (purple) real
Origin Setup Vector position duck (green) (real,real)
Angle Setup Real angle duck (blue) real
Length Setup Real real duck (cyan) real
Strength Setup Real <none> (PEND) real
SETUP LOCAL and RECURSIVE
To define a bone and manipulate it you only need to draw three ducks:
origin, angle, and tip. The tip is placed at the end of the bone length.
Due to there are two sets of ducks (setup and non setup) the user see
the corresponding ducks by pressing a toggle keyboard combination:
ALT-7: Toggles between setup and non setup ducks. (DONE)
Also to be able to see the local and recursive scales there is also other
toggle keyboard combination to do that:
ALT-8: Toggles between local and recursive scales ducks. (DONE)
The movement of the Length Scales (Local and Recursive) and Length Setup
ducks are restricted to be alingend with the current bone angle. (DONE)
Strength: Strength has not visual interface yet, but it should be like a
blob around the line that connects the Origin(0) and the Tip(0). It can
be represented by a dashed line like the one I draw in the wiki to explain
the "distance to a bone": See http://synfig.org/Image:Strength.png. (PEND)
The usage of Strength will be seen later.
All those ducks are modified by the Normal Tool of synfigstudio by click
and drag.
PARENT INTERFACE
----------------
The user can change the parentship using the mouse and without need to
expand the bone valuenode and select a parent in the drop down list.
In this way the user should see some visual interface to know
what's the parent of a bone without expanding the skeleton Bone
list. That parentship will be represented by an arrow. Usually the
arrow goes form child to parent. So a parent with lots of children
has a lot of arrows pointing to it. I think that the arrow should go from
child origin to parent origin. There is be a way to show/hide those arrows
to allow the user check the parent-child relationship during the animation
process. As well as parents are animatable those arrows changes by the
time too.
ALT-9 toggles parent arrows (PEND)
The arrow can point form parent to children. It is more consistent and
better visually. There is not need to have lots of arrows tips to be
overlapping on the parent origin. The arrows tips only goes to the
child, so as well as a child can only have a parent the arrows tips
doesn't overlap.
Work flow (PEND):
1) Two bones are not parented and the user want to make one (bone1)
the child of other (bone2). Then the user selects the origin of the
bone1 and right click the origin of the bone2 and select "Make
Parent" from the context menu.
2) Two bones are parent and child (bone2(child)<--bone1(parent))and
you want to unparent the child to select other parent (bone3). The
user selects the child (bone2) and do the same than case 1. Then
synfigstudio should do it in two steps (unparent bone2 from bone1
and parent bone2 to bone3). The result should be:
bone2(child)<--bone3(parent)
3) A bone is child of a parent and want to turn into a root bone. Just
select its origin and right click and select "Unparent" from the context
menu.
When the user tries to do illegal things (ie. make parent a child bone
or past child bone or future child bone) then the right click doesn't
offer the "Make Parent" option and only the "Unparent" one (that is
always valid)
SETUP AND ANIMATED SKELETONS
----------------------------
By using the ALT-7 keyboard combintation the user sees the setup or the
non setup skeletons.
When the user is creating the skeleton and is modifiying it in non
animation mode then the setuo and the non setup skeletons should be the
same. In this way the workflow for this creation of the skeleton will be:
1) In non animation mode and with no waypoints, modify the setup skeleton
should modify also the not setup skeleton. In this case there is not difference
between one skeleton and the other and the interface will mdify both at
the same time.
2) Once you're in animation mode you can modify either the setup skeleton
or the non setup skeleton. From the first modification both skeletons are
separated and distinguished. Toggle both to see the difference.
ADD BONE TOOL (PEND)
-------------
It is needed a new Add Bone tool like the Bline tool. That tool would
add bones to a new skeleton layer or to a existing skeleton layer.
WORKFLOW:
0) (optional) select a skeleton layer
1) Select the tool
2) (optional) CTRL-click to a origin of a bone and select it.
3) Left click where the origin should be.
4) Drag to where the tip should be.
5) Release mouse button and the bone is created. The origin of the new
bone is selected and any other origin bone is unselected.
If there were one origin bone selected then the new create bone becomes
a child of that bone, if not the new bone is root bone.
There are some options in the options tool panel:
1) Text entry: Bone name. It would use on the bone base name, like the
layers of other tools.
2) "Force create a new skeleton": if checked it always creates a new
skeleton layer regardless if there is a skeleton layer selected.
If the option force create a new skeleton is off then the new added bones
are:
a) Added to a new skeleton layer (if there weren't any skeleton layer selected
at step 0)
b) Added to the first skeleton layer of the selected layers
I suggest to use the code from the bline tool and the draw tool as
templates to create the new bone tool.
WEIGHT DUCKS (PEND)
------------
There are weights per vertex and per bone. So the weights can be seen
from the point of view of the bone or from the point of view of the vertex.
The most useful way of see the weights are frpm the point of view of the
vertex (or bilinepoint) that is bone influenced.
So a proposal for the interface is:
The user selects a vertex/blinepoint and the interface shows the weight(s)
of the bone(s) over that vertex/bilinepoint. It can be a radius duck centered
on the bone's tip.
"Select" means select it in the bline list or select the vertex parameter.
I don't know if it is possible to "select" it with the mouse (draw a red
square around) like if it is selected in the parameter panel.
---------------------not delete for reference only----------------------
(10:23:52) Carlos: there is also other thing I didn't mention about
the weights
(10:25:07) Carlos: if you pick a bline and pick a bone too then with
ALT-9 you can show a real duck over each vertex
(like the width ducks) to allow the user see and
modify individual weights)
(10:25:41) Carlos: in that state you can only pick a bone each time to
see only the influence of the bone on the bline
(10:26:28) Carlos: it is like draw the weights around the vertices
like the widths ducks are drawn.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
REMOVING and INSERTING A BONE
-----------------------------
Remove:
When the user selects a bone in the skeleton layer can do right click
and select remove item smart then the bone is removed from the list and
that DOESN'T DELETE A VALUENODE, it just removed the valuenode
form the list and keep it alive meanwhile anyone references to that
valuenode. Even the history can keep a valuenode alive if it is not
cleaned. So, any other bone that has that bone as parent keeps it as
parent. It will be alive until any children references to it as parent,
there were no history entry of it and it is not referenced in the child
panel or any other valuenode. (DONE)
So remove an item smart from a list keeps the valuenode in any place
where it has been used. For example the parent parameter.
It is reponsability of the user restore the correct parent of the other
bones if really he doesn't want that the removed bone belongs to the
skeleton anymore. (DONE)
The user can remove item smart by right click on the bone's origin duck
and selecting the "Remove item (smart)". (PEND)
Insert:
When the user selects a bone in the bone list and right click and selects
the "Insert item (smart)" option then a new bone is inserted, placed at
the tip of the origin of the bone where the right click was done and it is
a child of that bone where the right click was done. The rest of values
are the default ones. (PEND)
BIND BONES TO A VERTEX/BLINEPOINT
---------------------------------
Once the skeleton is created and the stuff is drawn it comes the step of
bind the bones to the vertex/blinepoints.
WORKFLOW:
1) The user selects the drawn stuff
2) The user selects a skeleton layer too.
3) The user selects a vertex/blinepoint or a group of them
4) The user does right click on a bone and select "Add to Bone Influence"
Then the GUI should add the current bone where the right click was done
to the Bone Weight Pair list of the selected vertices/blinepoints.
If the vertex/blinepoint is not converted to Bone influence then convert it
to that too first and add the bone after.
If the bone is already part of the Bone Weight pair list then do nothing.
The initial weight can be 1.0.
-----------------------DO NOT DELETE YET--------------------------------
So the user, in set up moment can ask to synfigstudio to assign a
weight to each bone weight pair based on the distance form the point
to the bone and the strength of the bone. For instance, if a point is
at the same "distance" from bone1 and from bone2 but bone1 has higher
strength than the bone2 then the weight value of the bone weight pair
for that particular point and for bone1 is higher than the weight of
the bone weight pair for the bone2. The relationship of the weight and
the distance and the strength is given by the formulations written in
this page: http://synfig.org/Talk:Bone_Layer. It can be simplified if
you want.
The "binding mode" (Fixed, Flexi-Binded, Region-Linear,
Region-parabolic) should be part of the skeleton layer so it can be a
parameter from a drop down list. It doesn't make sense this value to
produce any waypoint because it is just used in setup mode. Its
modification doesn't modify the current values of the weights of the
bone weight pairs. Only if the user override the current Vertex Bone
conversion and start it over then it can have a new usage.
------------------------------------------------------------------------